Murder Mysteries

Known as "Your Live Entertainment Destination," We at Memories do our best to provide exciting and unique answers to the eternal question: "What should we do for a killer evening of fun tonight?"


A murder mystery is a type of dinner theater performance in which audience members cooperate with each other and interact with the performers in order to solve a fictitious murder scene. Murder mysteries are most often comedic in nature and performed in coordination with a meal.

Prior to the show starting, the cast will mingle with the audience members going table to table introducing themselves. This is a great way for you to mingle with crazy characters and shady suspects while getting some insight as to just who each character is. As the night continues you will get to interrogate the suspects, gather the clues, and work with your team to help our mystery experts crack the case before the killer gets away!

Audience members are encouraged to put together an outfit that will complement the show you are about to see. This is another great way for you to feel like you are part of the show. However, if you choose not to dress up, you will still have a good time!

The goal of a murder mystery is for participants to enjoy a great meal, make new friends and gather clues provided throughout the evening and use them to deduce the identity and motive of the "murderer." Prizes are awarded to the table that is closest to solving the mystery, and one to the table that does not even come close!

We hope you will join us for one or more of our upcoming Murder Mysteries here at Memories.

A Hair Raising Halloween

A Hair Raising Halloween

October 18 - 20, 2024

Ticket Information

Tickets available anytime by clicking the Tickets link on each show description (service fees apply) or by calling during regular box office hours (Monday through Friday- 10:00 am til 4:00 pm or Saturdays 12:00 pm til 3:00 pm) at 262-284-6850.

Please note: Online ticket sales often close up to 2 days prior to the performance.  If online tickets are listed as unavailable, please contact Memories directly to inquire about availability. 

2024 Murder Mystery Ticket Pricing:

Dinner & Show

    • Advance Orders: $48*

*All tickets are subject to Wisconsin sales tax  


Ticket Types:

Dinner and Show Tickets: Include a buffet dinner featuring steak sandwiches and our parmesan garlic chips. These also include your show tickets. At Memories, you dine in the ballroom, so there is no need to move to a new table for the performance. Please arrive at least 15 minutes prior to dinner to be seated.

Enhance your Experience 

Celebration Package, available with any ticket purchase:
$60 + Tax (Show Tickets Not Included In The Package)
Celebration Package icon
For birthdays, engagements, anniversaries, retirements, or any milestone occasion, show the special people in your life how much they mean to you with a celebration package- now available for all live events. This special package includes:

  • One reserved, premier parking space for the honoree(s).
  • Beautiful take-home flower arrangement awaiting you at your table.
  • One Bottle of Champagne or Wine to toast your special occasion.
  • Public Announcement of your special celebration.
  • 8 Delectable Cupcakes. Additional cupcakes are available for purchase for $1.50 apiece.




Online ticket sales typically close 2 days prior to each performance, and occasionally, online tickets may sell out before box office tickets. To inquire about ticket availability, please contact Memories directly at 262-284-6850.


Cancellation Policy:

All reservations are final. No refunds will be given for canceled reservations.  Online service fees are non-refundable. 

Season Tickets

Create Your Season
Choose from our full lineup of shows and create your own season.

Season Tickets2024 Season Tickets - NOW AVAILABLE!

The More you Come, the More you Save!
You Choose the Dates and Shows
8 Show Package, Save 25%
5 Show Package, Save 15%
4 Show Package, Save 10%
(subject to availability)

Call the box office at 262-284-6850 to order

CREATE Your 2024 Season Ticket Package TODAY!

Theater Information


At Memories, upon their arrival, guests are escorted to their seats, where you can relax and enjoy your entire experience, as guests dine in the same ballroom where the performance takes place.

All seating is assigned based on the date of reservation. If you have a group you wish to be seated with, please call Memories directly or make one online reservation for your entire group.

Stage/Seating Types

Memories uses a proscenium setup with the stage in the front of the hall for Murder Mystery events. 

Hall Stage Proscenium

Proscenium is arranged with the stage in the front of the hall. 

Special Accommodations

Memories strives to provide an enjoyable experience for all our customers.  If special accommodations (walkers or wheelchairs) or dietary restrictions are needed, please contact Memories directly.

Hearing LoopT Coil Logo

Memories recently installed a hearing loop system.  Using the T-coil you can now listen to our shows through your hearing aids.  For those without this functionality, we offer portable headsets that can be checked out. 



Laughter is best shared with friends and family. Memories offers discounts for groups of 16 or more. Check out our Groups Page for more information. Then, call Memories directly at 262-284-6850 for a special rate.

Smaller group? Check out our Table of 8 Package under the Ticket Information below.


Table of 8 Special:
table 8 smGather your friends, family, or co-workers. Groups purchasing a table of eight will receive their choice of a complimentary bottle of house wine, a pitcher of beer, or pitcher of soda!

This special includes your tickets, a delicious dinner, and complimentary drinks as described above.  

*(Table of 8 Special requires an advance reservation and payment be made by one party)


What if I have a group of friends who all want to come to an event together?

At Memories, we are thrilled to see groups of friends and family enjoying a night together, experiencing great food and entertainment. To make a group reservation go as smoothly as possible, we strongly recommend that the group of guests select one person to make the reservation for the entire group. Upon making the reservation, you will be asked how many guests are in your group. Payment should be made at the time of reservation. Please inform your guests to check-in under the last name of the lead person, who made the reservation, on the night of your visit.


What if the guests of our group all want to pay for their own portion of the reservation?

We realize that it can be a rather large sum of money for one lead guest to make payment for a large group at once. If that is not a viable option, Memories asks that the lead guest call in the reservation for their group and notify the box office at that time that other guests will be calling in their payment separately (Memories accepts Visa, Master Card or Discover). At that time, the lead person should also supply Memories with the list of guest names and how many guests are being paid for under each guest's name. Then, when each guest calls in to make payment on their portion of the reservation, our box office staff will locate their name in the previously supplied list and credit the payment to that portion of the reservation.

***Please take note: All Murder Mystery seating is pre-assigned by Memories' staff. If a group reservation is not organized in the manner described above, Memories CANNOT guarantee we will be able to grant post-reservation seating requests to individuals making separate reservations.

Murder Mystery FAQ

Is seating done on a first-come/first-serve basis?

As with all Memories entertainment events, seating is done on a priority-basis. This means that as the event date draws near, the box office refers to the admission/guest reservation purchase log for that day and begins filling in the tables from the front of the theatre and works back, in order of when the order was placed and paid for. Therefore, the sooner you make your reservation and payment, the closer to the stage you will be seated..

Do you allow walk-ins?

While we do accept walk-in guests on the night of the event (pending availability), it is strongly recommended to make reservations prior to arriving at Memories for a Murder Mystery. To prevent disappointment upon arriving to an event and being turned away, due to lack of available seats, making a reservation in advance is your best option to ensuring you won't miss out on these killer events.